Skip to content

Insights

An anthropologist’s message to business: neither chasing trends nor thorough market analysis will save you

Rokas Atkočiūnas · IMPACT Advisory strategist, anthropologist

An anthropologist’s message to business: neither chasing trends nor thorough market analysis will save you

In the media we constantly read about newly founded companies in Lithuania and their new products. All this buzz on the surface creates an optimistic image of a lively market, especially since this year has been promised to us as the tenth year of uninterrupted economic growth. Unfortunately, this growth hides quite a few business casualties. According to official data from Statistics Lithuania, more than 19,000 businesses went bankrupt between 1993 and 2017. Since behind every such business “corpse” lies wasted energy and money thrown away, the question naturally arises: could we reduce the number of casualties at least a little?

Only 60% survive longer than a year

Business failures even increased during the period of economic growth: 1,450 businesses went bankrupt in 2013, 1,607 in 2014, 1,858 in 2015, 2,203 in 2016 and 2,868 in 2017. It is also worth noting that every year the number of registered businesses is almost twice the number of active ones. Moreover, according to market experts, the share of companies that survive longer than a year has hovered around 60% in recent years, while the number of new companies is growing much faster than the number of active ones.

The question is why the market spits out these unsuccessful 40%, even though these were companies with ideas, visions, plans and funds. Some of them probably also relied on business consultants and thorough market analysis, and explored the market they were interested in themselves. So what happened?

Anthropology could offer an answer. In the eyes of an anthropologist, essentially all business analyses rest on the image of a stable world. In other words, one of the assumptions of such analyses is that tomorrow will be exactly the same as yesterday. This imagined stability makes it possible to name assumptions, put forward hypotheses and project results. However, stability is not a feature of our time that we can rely on. We live in times of rapid and fundamental change, so we need a broader, non-linear view of business and society.

Business: not for theory, but for people

Modern technology allows us to analyse huge amounts of data in a very short time, which helps us form a clearer picture of human behaviour. Still, this picture is not enough, and the picture of human behaviour itself does not remove the fundamental need to analyse and interpret it. This is exactly where an anthropologist can help: someone who knows very well that an abundance of data is not an answer in itself, and that a deep understanding of what the data hides and reveals is needed. If we cannot read what the picture of human behaviour tells us, we will not be able to predict consumer behaviour or change it. We will simply be doomed to keep fishing in unfamiliar waters or picking mushrooms in a forest that is completely foreign to us: instead of building a business that creates opportunities, we will chase trends or react to them. Even if such a model can hit the mark (even a broken clock is right twice a day), the principle of reacting is essentially the principle of a passive business, bound by dependence on other market players or on the dictate of external factors, and that is not sustainable.

For an anthropologist, people matter more than theory. The anthropological point of view helps to discover new things instead of what has been reduced to supposedly well-known “eternal truths”. Instead, it brings out the phenomena and dynamics of human life that essentially shape the challenges and problems a business faces. For example, if a bank is planning a pension programme, an anthropologist starts with questions such as how ageing is understood in that particular society and which life events shape a person’s attitude to saving for old age. Or, if a cosmetics company is developing a beauty product, an anthropologist starts with questions such as how beauty is understood in that particular society, which life events shape a person’s attitude to the importance of beauty, or when and why a person needs to be beautiful. Insights like these are better “grounded” and therefore more fundamental: they depend less on the whims of fashion, stay valid longer and can help to assess newly emerging problems.

Anthropologists offer scenarios

An analysis of entrepreneurship in Lithuania and the large number of very short-lived companies and products suggest that many business decisions are based on dead theories and on classic interpretations of human behaviour that no longer fit our times. It is therefore no coincidence that various teams of strategists complement the business development models used so far not only with marketing expertise but also with anthropology, offer platforms of integrated tools and organise business workshops. This may seem unusual in Lithuania, but there are many tandems of anthropologists and business people around the world. One example is ReD, a strategy consultancy operating in the US and Denmark, whose work over the past decade is rightly associated with a revolution in business thinking.

In workshops of this kind, business representatives are invited to develop the new product projects they bring with them. It is less about learning and more about working: the strategic and practical steps of a specific offer are laid out from the ground up so that the offer is relevant and valuable to the market and motivates consumers to use the product or service. Ultimately, of course, this helps the business achieve the financial result it wants.

A similar practice would probably also benefit small and medium-sized businesses in Lithuania, which make up most of those 40% of newly founded companies that, unfortunately, do not survive even a year. It would be an opportunity to study the business environment without preconceptions, avoiding conclusions that are supposedly “discovered” but in fact merely dictated by prior assumptions and unrelated to reality. It could also be one of the ways to overcome a possible crisis, and financial analysts are already urging business people to create such scenarios this year.